|
Over
the past two weeks the main stream media,
announced to anyone who may have failed to
notice, that the market was 20% off its lows and
thus a "new bull market had arrived!"
Normally, we do not bother to comment on
silliness, but this one, is so silly we can't
ignore it! It takes more than just a 20% rally
to signal the birth of a new bull market. In
case you have any doubts consider the following
charts
 
The
chart on the left, is the NDX over the past 18
months. We had -at least- three rallies in
excess of 20%, yet the NDX continued to
collapse. If the notion that a 20% advance
constitutes the birth of a new bull market is
correct, then over the past 18 months, the NDX
has had not one, but at least, three glorious
bull markets, and your brokerage account balance
should reflect the "gains" made in
these three bull markets! However,
our guess is, that most investors'
statements reflect exactly the opposite. The
chart on the right, is the NIKKEI over the past
twenty years, as it can be seen very clearly
between 1992 and 2000, the index has had three
monster-size rallies in excess of 20%, yet just
six weeks ago, it made 17 year lows! The point
is this: markets can rally and fall, for the
right reasons, as well as, for the wrong ones.
If there is one thing that by now should clear
to investors is the fact that Mr. Market
is not always right, in fact the past two years
he has been ridiculously wrong! Could it
be right this time? MAYBE, BUT NOT CERTAINLY.
Be open-minded but do not get trapped by
trusting the market 100%.
 |
Now
that we got that out of our system,
let's examine critically whether the
economy has indeed bottomed. Our own
research -as recently as- three weeks ago,
was indicating that any recovery, would
not begin to take place until late 2002.
However, over the past three weeks, some
of the data that have come out, show
credible evidence that indeed the recovery
may start earlier. One of our most trusted
indicators, is the ECRI's Weekly
Leading Index (see http://economy.com)
As we can see very clearly, the economy
has been in a sharp downtrend since
mid-2000. We have had two previous
instances, in which the Index rose , to
only collapse later. At the moment, it is
experiencing the third such rise, will it
hold this time? The truth is, WE DO NOT
KNOW WITH ANY CERTAINTY, however, we are |
certain,
that nobody else does either!, especially, the
silly talking heads who steadfastly claim that
they do. For sure there are positive signals
coming from other corners -besides the equity
markets- Yields on junk bonds, have fallen over
the past two weeks, the spread between
investment grade bonds and junk bonds have
narrowed as well. The Federal Funds
futures indicate a less than 30% probability, of
another rate cut at the next FOMC meeting. Last
but not least, copper is up nearly 10%, in the
past copper has been a rather reliable leading
indicator. In addition, it looks that consumer
spending may hold going forward. Consumer
confidence has been rising, energy costs are
lower, low interest rates provide not only more
disposable income, but also support for the
housing market, and last but not least, the
consumer will get another boost from additional
tax cuts. So, one can make the case that the
resilient American consumer, much like the
"Energizer Bunny" will keep on
going. The government's hope is that the
consumer will keep on going, until the corporate
sector finally rids itself of the excesses in
capacity, and it catches up with the consumer
sector. On that front, we are not very
optimistic.
| Sector |
Number
Of Publicly Traded Technology
Companies |
| Computer
Hardware |
170 |
| Software |
504 |
| Semiconductors |
418 |
| Internet |
282 |
| Telecom |
393 |
| Total
Technology |
1767 |
| Total
Number Of All Publicly Traded
Companies (NYSE, AMEX, NASDAQ) |
7487 |
| Percentage:
Technology in relation to the total
number of publicly traded companies |
23.60%
Source:
TC2000 |
|
The
real problem facing the U.S. economy, is
not just excess capacity and
inventories in technology companies. The
real problem lies in too many
technology companies, making too much of
the same stuff, most companies have
already bought too much of! Almost one
quarter of all publicly
traded companies in the three major
exchanges (NYSE, AMEX, NASDAQ) are
technology companies! Do we really
need that many technology companies? We
think not! The problem with so many
companies crowding one field, is that they
cause everybody's margins to shrink, thus
reducing corporate profits for everyone.
Historically, diminished corporate
profits, have preceded mass lay-offs,
which we think will eventually happen. If
that scenario takes place, consumer
confidence and spending will take a turn
for the worse. |
Until,
companies that should not be in business, are no
longer in business, the U.S economy will not
grow at its full potential. Instead, it will be
"saddled" by dead weight, causing it
to grow at a "sub-par" rate. Ten
months ago we commented:
"...If
this is the scenario currently unfolding in the
U.S. we would expect prices to initially
continue modestly higher -as investors
mistakenly convince themselves that downturn is
cyclical, not secular- However, later in the
year, as it becomes evident that what we are
dealing with is a secular trend, equity prices
will head back down again. In such case, NASDAQ
will easily penetrate its recent lows, and we
would expect it to reach 1800-1400 before
year’s end"
(See January 2001 Newsletter "Half
Empty Or Half Full?" 1-15-2001
So
far, our predictions and forecasts have been
rather accurate. Of course, that does not
guarantee "perpetual accuracy"
but it does give our forecasts
credibility. Compare our opinion of the
economy and the markets on 1-15-01, to the
opinion of Mr. Battipaglia, Chief Investment
Strategist of Grunthall and Co. just 13 says
earlier.
"1/2/01-As
investment in technology grows in terms of its contribution to
the overall economy, I expect to see continued gains in the
non-cyclical component of the productivity data.
My
own estimate for earnings growth still calls for a 14 percent
year-over-year improvement in S&P 500 operating earnings for
2001.
Accordingly,
I am raising my sector rating on transportation companies from
"neutral" to "outperform" at this time.
As
demand for U.S. made products rises, our trade and current
account deficits should ease. Also, rising exports should be
additive to overall GDP growth.
Look
for 2001 to be a year of positive surprises. We are adding
transportation companies to our "outperform"-rated
sectors, alongside financials pharmaceuticals, and technology.
Our 2001 year-end targets remain 12,700 on the Dow 1,625
on the S&P 500 and 4,300 on the Nasdaq"
(source" www.capitalstool.com)
It
should be noted that Mr. Battipaglia is again
wildly bullish! he scary part is that most Wall
Street Strategists, are sharing his view.We are
just skeptical. It would make us very
uncomfortable, if by any chance, we found
ourselves sharing the same views.
It
should be noted that in a little publicized
research paper, Merrill Lynch reported
that the consensus equity allocation among Wall
Street strategists is now 76%, "truly
unbelievable", and an all-time high. The
report notes "there was never a subsequent
12-month return that was negative when readings
were below 50%. By contrast, subsequent 12-month
returns were positive only half the time when
readings were above 60%, and never outperformed
cash when readings were above 61%." The
indicator projects a 12-month market loss of
more than 25%. (source: http://www.hussman.com/hussman/members/updates/latest.htm)
Now let's
take a look at the technical condition of the
equity markets.
Our
Market Positions:
Dow: Bearish,SP500:Bearish
NASDAQ:Bearish
|